Recent federal disclosures continue to expose the union-busting industry’s financial footprint, revealing which employers are spending hundreds of dollars per hour and sometimes thousands per day to prevent workers from organizing. The latest filings, submitted to the Department of Labor’s Office of Labor-Management Standards, show corporations across healthcare, logistics, and technology sectors investing heavily in anti-union campaigns.
Follow the Money
The LM-20 forms, which consultants must file when hired to influence worker organizing efforts, paint a clear picture of where corporate priorities lie. While companies often claim budget constraints when workers request better wages or benefits, these same organizations are willing to invest heavily in campaigns designed to discourage unionization.
According to this week’s filings, the pattern of expensive consultant engagements continues. Northwell Health, one of New York’s largest healthcare systems, retained Heightened Solutions at $475 per hour to combat organizing efforts at their New Hyde Park facility. Capstone Logistics in Georgia hired The Crossroads Group Labor Relations Consultants at the same $475 hourly rate to counter an organizing campaign
Amazon’s engagement at their Durham, North Carolina facility (DRT8) demonstrates the resources committed to these efforts. The company brought in consultant Keith Williams at $2,200 per day to fight organizing efforts by CAUSE (Carolina Amazonians United for Solidarity and Empowerment). This daily rate represents money that could alternatively fund worker compensation, safety improvements, or operational investments. Instead, it’s being directed toward persuading employees not to exercise their legal right to organize.
The Healthcare Industry’s Anti-Union Investment
Northwell Health’s decision to hire expensive union-busting consultants is particularly notable given the healthcare industry’s ongoing staffing crisis and worker burnout concerns. The $475 per hour investment in Heightened Solutions demonstrates the organization’s willingness to deploy substantial resources against its own workforce’s organizing efforts, even as healthcare workers nationwide have faced unprecedented challenges.
These consultant fees flow out of company budgets during a time when healthcare workers are seeking better staffing ratios, improved safety protocols, and fair compensation. The choice to invest in union avoidance rather than addressing worker concerns directly speaks volumes about organizational priorities.
Amazon’s Continued Anti-Union Spending
Amazon’s engagement of Keith Williams at $2,200 per day represents the latest chapter in the company’s well-documented resistance to worker organizing. The Durham facility joins a growing list of Amazon locations where the company has deployed expensive consultants to counter unionization efforts.
CAUSE, the union organizing workers at the Durham facility, represents a grassroots effort by Amazon employees seeking improved working conditions and a voice in workplace decisions. The company’s substantial investment in consultant fees underscores how seriously Amazon takes these organizing efforts, even as it publicly discusses its commitment to employee welfare.
The Consultant Playbook
These labor relations consultants bring a well-established arsenal of tactics designed to discourage union organizing. Understanding these methods is crucial for workers navigating organizing campaigns.
Consultants frequently disseminate misleading information about unions, exaggerating dues costs while downplaying potential benefits, or suggesting that unionization will lead to job losses or facility closures. They orchestrate “captive audience meetings” where workers are coerced into attending anti-union presentations during work hours, creating an environment where dissent feels risky and management’s message is inescapable.
Surveillance of organizing activity is another common tactic. Consultants work to identify union supporters, assess vulnerabilities in organizing committees, and sometimes recommend targeting pro-union employees for additional scrutiny or discipline. They also train supervisors to conduct one-on-one meetings with employees, gathering personal information that can later be used to craft individualized persuasion strategies.
What This Means for Workers
For workers considering unionization, these disclosures offer an important lesson: when employers hire expensive consultants, it signals that organizing efforts are being taken seriously. The substantial investment in union avoidance demonstrates that employers recognize the potential power shift that collective bargaining represents.
Workers should approach mandatory meetings, one-on-one conversations with supervisors, and company communications about unions with a critical eye during organizing campaigns. The information being presented has likely been carefully crafted by highly paid professionals whose job is to discourage unionization, not to provide balanced perspective on workers’ rights.
The LM-20 filing system exists precisely because transparency matters. Workers have a right to know when their employer has brought in outside help to influence their decisions about workplace representation. As these recent filings show, that outside help comes with a significant price tag—money that reveals just how much employers value keeping workers from organizing.
Support Independent Labor Reporting
Following the money in union-busting requires meticulous research, data analysis, and a commitment to transparency. LaborLab makes this information freely available because workers deserve to know when their employers are spending thousands per day to keep them voiceless.
If you found this reporting valuable, please consider supporting our work with a $5 monthly sustaining donation. Your contribution helps us:
- Monitor and analyze federal labor disclosures as they’re filed
- Expose corporate anti-union spending across industries
- Provide workers with the information they need during organizing campaigns
- Maintain our independence from corporate influence
For less than the cost of a coffee each month, you can help ensure this critical reporting continues. Become a sustaining donor today.
LaborLab is a nonprofit organization dedicated to transparency in labor relations. All donations support our investigative work.